Hypothetical build questions…

So looking through my cam stash, aside from a few big mechanicals, I have:

An oldskool Mopar Purple cam
#P4452761AE
Lift is .450/.455
Dur. Adv. is 268/272
@0.050 228/231
110 Lsa
1500-5800rpm

Or a Comp Cams Nostalgia Plus
#CL20-671-4
Lift is .484/.484
Dur. Adv. 284/291
@0.050 239/246
108Lsa
2500-6400rpm

Not gonna lie, that Comp will make 30hp over that old MP, and that is tempting…