I'm not going to say that is impossible but I think with the information provided that conclusion could be a bit of a leap. Unless you have more data to support that conclusion that wasn't in the post. How was it determined that the motor was lean to begin with? On the first carb did they try unpluging the mixture control solenoid and jetting the carb up to confirm that the motor was lean? Were they using et as their measuring stick for improvement? More details on this test please.