Disappointing dyno results

After carefully reviewing your posted cam specs I believe that your problem is not your cam.
agree.

either the cam is somehow wrong: marked incorrectly, ground incorrectly or installed incorrectly or there is something amiss with the rest of the setup: compression ratio calculated wrong, flatted out some lobes on break in, distributor is off time, carb is only getting 3/4 of throw from whatever apparatus they've got hooked up.