2.76 vs 3.23 vs 3.55

Define "fair amount" of time on the freeway?

3.55 is generally seen as the best "compromise" gearset for highway/city driving. 4.10 can be as well. Can't speak as to RPM until we know your rear tire height. 2.76 - 3.55 is gunna make a huge difference. Your 318 will feel a lot bigger!
I would think 3.23's are the best compromise.