Swinging for Divorce…

I like your math… problem with bat is it can get wet without me having a wrap outside of the wood frame. Also I have 0 desire to mess with fiberglass insulation. Also propane is way expensive!

My biggest heat loss right now is in the roof and the back sliding garage door. The roof where it meets the outer walls has pretty big gaps and the back sliding garage door has gaps on both sides of it. Those 2 things will have to be fixed and then it will hold heat in here no problem, at least good enough for the girls I go with.

You can see the cracks in these pictures. I haven’t decided how I will fix the garage door yet…

View attachment 1716189206

View attachment 1716189207

I don't disagree with your logic at all. That's why with batt I'd be putting osb in all the cavities first, or maybe tyvek first then osb over it in all the bays to keep water out. A vapor barrier inside wouldn't be a bad idea either if using fg, to keep any water vapor inside from migrating through to the metal sheathing and condensing there.

But yeah, fiberglass still sucks *** to deal with no matter what. I'm just a cheap ***, LOL.