Speedometer question: 1960 Valiant

The needle is missing, so assuming the entire unit needs to be replaced. Question is do I go with this junkyard find and hope it works or go with this apparently NOS Wagner unit? A 100% restore is not critical to me, but I'd like to keep the visual integrity the same, by having the center cover intact. Thank you in advance for advice.

s-l960.png

s-l1600 (2).jpg