Stop in for a cup of coffee

If it's reading but off that should be the sending unit itself... i use a spectra but no idea if it's accurate as i have only had like 2 gallons in my tank so far
That's what I'm thinking. I haven't been driving it enough to see it cycle up and down. I bought a used tank at local yard and I think I ended up using the sender that came with that. Not certain if it was an original, or aftermarket. It worked pretty well over the full range when installed.