Probably within spec. Slip ring to slip ring the rotor resistance should be 3 to 4 ohms at room temperature. The carbon brushes work well as a conductor when spinning but can show a lot of resistance when measured with a meter like that. But at least we know it's not open.
Good. So no short there.
Good.
Assuming the old alternator has a grounded brush holder, that would eliminate something related to the grounding wire used with the insulated brushes.
And in a previous test it started when the grounding wire was disconnected.
So that seems to narrow it down to the section of the circuit. Maybe there's a short or partial short somewhere in there.
Next places to disconnect during starting are each end of the field wire (R3), at the VR, and then at the alternator.