What did I do? Help?

Are you ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN you did not screw up on the plug wiring, or timing light cylinder selection? Do you have a light that is NOT "dial up?"
Never moved a single wire. I still checked twice. I have a snap on Dial light and a not dial up both reading accurate. I can't really vouch how good the other dizzy is. I do have a new pick up I can install but the engine runs great. Just the timing read out is whacked.