Engine stalls when you pull number 5 spark plug wire.

Yup, #5 is doing all the work. What heat range spark plugs? Check the resistance of the spark plug leads.
Champion RC12Yc. I checked the resistance numerous times. Also used a new set of MSD wires including new cap. Same results.

Also check INSIDE the dist cap...& rotor....for arcing.
Only thing I saw is that the reluctor gap was too big. The pick up plate in those firecore/summit distributors really sucks. It is kind of loose and ensures that the distance is not the same between the top and bottom of the pick-up, making it difficult to adjust the distance.