Horsepower Estimate?

just so you know 92 mph@ 3600lbs gets your 383 road runner or 383 dart 216 hp using that calc
my 68 gts was 3420 without me in it
my 70 duster 340 4spd was 3610 with me in it
I don't get why people think those calculators are more accurate then a dyno, any other time a rule of thumb or a formula is brought up it's dismissed as nonsense or at best a huge ballpark area. And since the dyno is supposedly unreliable there's no way to verify these formulas plus there's like 5 of them and they don't even agree with one another, to me they seem to tell you minimum hp needed if everything is setup a 110%.

So every car that weighs X lbs and goes Y mph is the exact same hp, I don't think so. What about the rest of the hp curve don't matter ? Same with tires, gearing, stall, aero, driver etc.. ?