Motor mount issue driving me crazy

Thanks mbaird I think I must have either one or both on backwards. I have the raised rubber bumps lined up in the holes of the mounts. Does that passenger side mount look right to you? I wouldn't think the mount would overhang the bracket by that much.

I definitely think I had the driver side mount on backwards. I found some better reference pics and will copy that tomorrow and see what happens. I'm thinking I may have flipped that one on my install after I removed the thicker mounts and that's what's causing my whole issue.

Thought about loosening them and tightening them after like you described but I didn't want to break a tab since everything was just so ill fitting.