Good post.
I'll not comment about moparts only beause its a side track. Oh wait - maybe I should because all threads should have side tracks! LOL.
Gold help on cell phones? No idea.
The problems I have had (and I'm pretty sure Redfish's are similar) are with computers. So maybe not relevant at all to this thread! I think its is software issue and buried deeper - not just a question of ads as it happens when logged in (Gold) or not logged in. Hasn't happened since th elast FABO crash.
As far as the Gold membership provides support and therefore a person's right to request improvement, you nailed it. This site might exist with 100% paid members or might not. However, it would not exist without members who contribute help and knowledge. They are what makes the site - not the $40 per year.