Would you risk it? What would you do?

Here is a example, this is a brand new, fresh out of the box elgin hyd lifter. Just took a very light cut, you can see the spherical radius ground on the face is off center. This lifter would have never rotated properly, and would have failed. Not to mention, surface finish looked like it was done with a DA sander

View attachment 1716316935

View attachment 1716316936
Would you worry about Comp Cams solid lifters? I know they are pre 2005 plus some.
Who would you get new SFT solids from? 440 source and Comp look to be only options