Would you reuse it?

Rollmasters are spendy but well worth the coin. I for sure wouldn't use any nylon gear even if new and free.
had a quick poke around, rollmasters are like 90 on fleabay and cloyes (which i think would be totally fine for this application) are about 70.

so sub 100 bones for peace of mind? ship it!

*the rollmaster has an adjustable keyway for maximum shenanigans, so that'd be my call.