I love Evaporust!

I tried same thing, it goes thru a chemical change and loses its strength. Key is to use it warm and fill as many voids as possible.
Have to get creative with trays/containers/tubes. For example don't use a gallon to clean a wrench. Use just enough to keep part saturated.
5 gallon pail here is over $100, so try to make it last.
With my military discount at O'Reily's, i am able to buy a 5 gallon of Evaporust in the low $90.00 dollar figure.