Aftermarket wheels, 17" (maybe 18) BBP

If you are buying aftermarket and have the option, different offsets would make it more bolt on for sure.

I'm thinking I may end up that route. The Dusters have such different tracks that anything else will be limited on fit and/or look incredibly weird.

If you want cheap and/or used and easily available (e.g. Mustang), you might need spacers in the back depending on what you find if you want to keep your current axle.

I'm very uncomfortable with spacers.

Might be worth doing some figuring and determine your current backspacing/offset so you can get an idea of what might fit.

Currently has what look like stock Rally wheels, 14" front, 15" rear. Not sure the offset, but looks factory...ish?