P205/75 R14 or P215/70 R14
i don't know if you were lumping milestar in with the cheap hong kong phooey tires or not?
but i agree, there's several cromulent tires available in that size-- those toyo's or some Khumo's would probably be my choice for a value buy if i didn't want to spend cooper cobra money (and i'm not buying BFG's).
can confirm on tire rack though. i bought the potenza RE's and had them mounted and balanced at the homestead. the tires had a special going so i got a smoking deal, free shipping and the guy that did the install was very professional.