P205/75 R14 or P215/70 R14
The big thing is there's no "everything is in one store". What I did is I researched a bunch of tire shops. I've also looked at Les Shwab, Vulcan Tire, Big-O and checked a local chain Buffalo Bros.
Funny, the kids at Buffalo Bros. begged me to bring in my car for them to work on, once I finish replacing ball joints I might take them up on their offer as I will need an alignment.
14 and 15 inch tire selections are getting more and more scarce. A buddy of mine wanted 255/60R15 tires for his Nova, I told him "good luck" you generally have 2 selections, 3 at most.
At Summit Racing (you think Tire Rack is supposedly expensive, try shopping tires here) you have a little more selection but it's mostly Street Radial drags and specialty tires that are $300+ a pop.
I really liked Tire Rack's site mainly for their research articles and as they did some numerous head to head testing on the various tires based on categories.
@junkyardhero
Well, Milestars are actually Taiwanese. Never had these tires myself but I did find out that Maxxis, Kenda and Federal are all Taiwanese.
I have Toyo Extensa's right now and I'm loving it. The Japanese make some good tires. Kumho's are Korean and they're ok... I had Sailun's before and they were ugh... Not good. Another Korean company Nexen is decent.
Us Koreans need to get our **** together if we want to get keep up with those Nipponese dorks.