Insulating a metal shop?

The kraft paper on the batts kills the lights too. You need to put up Sheetrock or OSB and paint it white, either way.
In my previous two garages I installed 1/2" (nominal) OSB panels and then painted them white. In comparison to sheetrock, much less risk of punch something through it (bicycle handles, for instance), and much easier to mount storage accessories and what not. And the white finish just made the place all that brighter.

Since it's worked twice before, looks like I may do it again in the new place.