Dodge Door Handle gaskets???

Hey everybody, just a quick question. I have a 69 Dart 2 Door and am wondering where did you buy your door handle gaskets??? i bought gaskets for the door handles on my car and they actually turned out to be thick black gaskets so when i put them on they stuck out and now the car looks like the door handles were gooped up with some silicone to the door and looks bad. Arent the gaskets supposed to be clear and thin so you cant even tell a gasket is there so everything looks flush?

thanks