A seemingly odd question

I use State Farm for my regular insurance and have been happy with them so far. My wife and I pay the same for 4 vehicles as you were quoted for 1. Just make sure you're not opting for full collision covereage, just get liabilty and property damage (and comprehensive if you want) or else you will take it in the shorts with high premiums. The first 2 cover any damage you might cause to someone else, their vehicle, or their property. Comprehensive covers acts of God to your vehicle (creaming a deer etc.). Collision covers your vehicle if it your fault ... but I ususally drop this when my vehicle's value drops below what collision costs me per year. Also, get them to play around with the deductible.