Center Console Shifter Plastic Insert Issue

I'm looking for input as to how to correct this problem with my Dart's center console shift area. As you can see in the photos, the plastic insert which surrounds the shift lever is broken. It's been this way since I purchased the car three years ago, and I'm about to gut the interior to prep it for subframe connectors to be welded onto the floor pan.
Have any of you dealt with this before, and if so, how did you fix it? It may be immediately obvious as to a solution when I remove the console, but thought I'd pose the question here to the Group for consideration.
Thanks for the assistance.