Should I hold them to the price?

grassy said
..hold them to it...it is only fair..great price, eh ?

I agree.And also with the Karma statement. Now if the seller had dun you wrong in the past I would demand the valve covers and go after them.

You asking for opinions shows you have doubts. Let them off the hook.It may go easier on your conciense.

Oh I see you did just that. I agree with ocdart,your a good guy!