You're right, I don't know what I was thinking when I wrote that. I've seen both snorkle and unsilenced with and without the breather fitting. I don't remember seeing an unsilenced with the band clamp though....only the snorkle type seem to have that. I've had Darts, Valiants, and Barracudas with both types of air cleaners. What determined the type air cleaner that was installed?