67 Barracuda lower quarter patch. Goodmark or Sherman?

[ESP47]

After I removed the trunk extension on my Barracuda, I noticed a softball sized crunched in dent on the lower quarter panel with body filler spaghetti coming through it.

Ordered an AMD patch panel from another site and it's been on back order all summer. Called AMD and it looks like it's not even going to be made until sometime next year.

So now I'm down to either Goodmark or Sherman. Both are relatively the same price on Rockauto so I was just wondering which one you guys think I will have to do less work to? I'm not doing a full quarter, just a lower patch to get the dent and body filler out of there.

 

[toplscuda]

Both are pretty much the same and since you are only doing a patch as long as you don't get into any major body lines you should be ok. They just don't have as sharp of bodylines stamped into them. If you were replacing the whole skin you would have to deal with the waviness of the panel.

 

[crewchief]

Goodmark and Sherman parts don't fit as well as AMD. Toplscuda is right as far as fit and finish. Even AMD's full quarters need a little tweaking to fit perfectly. They are a much better producer of aftermarket sheetmetal than the others. They are MoPar certified reproduction suppliers.