A scathing review of a POS and dangerous Klein tester

-

67Dart273

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Messages
60,611
Reaction score
34,097
Location
Idaho
My best Fluke may not make it. It powers up with a new battery, but it was somewhat warm, and the battery leaked. The others I have in the basement are "smokey."

So I thought I'd buy an inexpensive tester to get by until I get something better, or see about getting the Flukes cleaned up. I bought the small one, could not really see in the package very well. It turns out:

For reference, the meter is about 5" long x 1 1/2 wide, and a bit difficult to juggle, but the POS and dangerous part is this: The leads from point to entrance in the tool are only 9" and there is no way, as in popular testers, to insert one test prod into the rear of the case so that the entire tool can be hung on to and used as a prod. Worse, the test prods are only about 2 5/8 OAL so getting your fingers tangled in something is a possibility. So here you are, trying to reach a hot spot in the box, etc, while dangling this miserable toy, and trying to keep it dangling so that you can see the lights. The leads are nowhere near long enough. And why in hell does it need a battery? I had a tester, decades ago, with scaled lights and it needed no battery. And I actually FOUND my old solenoid type tester, a Knopp K60. NO BATTERY!!

And you can still BUY them!!


The thing about the K60 is, they call it a "low impedance" tester. I has a sort of solenoid in there that activates the moving needle, and that solenoid prevents you from being fooled by "phantom voltage" as can happen with solid state multimeters
Below, the ol' reliable Knopp
KnoppK60.jpg

Bought this kit today for 40 bucks.
KleinMulti kit.jpg

This POS is dangerous and useless and should be outlawed
KleinDangerousTester.jpg
 
Last edited:
I love my Square D "Wiggy" testers.

1726140283499.png


Kinda surprised Klein would sell something like that considering their reputation.
I see they are trying to increase their market share by selling more at big box home stores.
Perhaps that extends to lower "consumer quality" items.
 
I have a Fluke 88 with a 400a induction pick-up and several different leads. Does everything I need it to do. It even has a super low ohm scale as a power up option and an induction pick-up that makes it a digital tachometer. Very happy with it's performance.
 
-
Back
Top