I used a black plastic cover in my 1970 Dart and it looks awesome! I bought it on ebay, the fit was excellent, the only spot where you can notice it doesn't cover all the way is the part where the dash pad curves down the side edge, hard to even see. The grain is pretty close too. I had to cut the old dash pad down where the cracks flared up, otherwise it wouldn't glue down all the way. My cover came with silicone to hold it down. Make sure you use a lot of it to hold it down in every spot, use a lot of weight to hold it down, I used a bunch of mopar parts manuals! I left the weight on it for a full day. I didn't have to remove the dash pad. I did have to pull back (not out) the gauge cluster and radio/heater bezel where the pad tucks under but that was easy. My car has a black interior so I didn't even have to paint it, I put armorall on it and it looks good enough for a show car. Cheap fix till I can get a new pad. I felt the money (about $50) spent for this was well worth it! Keith.