Need some advise for my Duster.

[jbmopars]

I am trying to buy a reproduction cardboard headliner for my Duster. Which one do I want to buy, the vinyl covered ABS plastic version? My original headliner is a textured cardboard type material. I also notice Legandary's catalog says the fit is FAIR, can anyone tell me what is wrong with the fit? Thanks in advance, Jody