I agree that the color of the car really makes a difference. I have a triple black 72 Swinger and the vinyl top really sets if off. We older guys grew up in a time when vinyl tops were pretty common, so maybe the younger guys don't care form them. (Although they do have kind of an "old school" look to them. The guy who replaced mine said he has been doing it for close to 30 years, and he used to do 3 a day. Now he says he averages about 3 per month. One thin for sure, it's a hellva lot easier to Armor All a vinyl top then it is to wax a painted one.