I painted all of it, rear uppers, roof rail, a-pillar plastics too. I say I'll try to correct it all someday.
The dash and steering column are a suede finish that really doesn't match anything else. Kind of matches the dash pad.
Here's an idea, If you have black lower vent(s) in the door(s), remove one and try to match the best/newest looking part of it, color and sheen. I have to think that's how the factory did it. They matched spray paint to those adjacent plastic parts.