More 2cents
In my younger years I did put the bigport heads and 340 cam into a LOW-CR 318..... twice;once for another guy and once for me. and both were DOGS below 3000, going to less doggy with rpm, but sortof ok as the rpm finally woke up.
I have refused to do it ever afterward.
In my cases
the bottom got so soft, the stock TC stall dropped several hundred rpm, and 2.94s were impossibly slow until 42 mph in first gear/70 in second. I got me a 2800 to get off the line, but it did not much for the slow acceleration. That took 3.91s to liven up.
And here's how that combo looks@930ft elevation;
Static compression ratio of 8:1.
Effective stroke is 2.57 inches.
Your dynamic compression ratio is 6.43:1 .
Your dynamic cranking pressure is 117.59 PSI.
V/P (Volume to Pressure Index) is 87
VP of 87!!!!
You know what else has a VP of 87? I'll tell you, here's a stock 1969 - 225cuber
Static compression ratio of 8.4:1.
Effective stroke is 3.62 inches.
Your dynamic compression ratio is 7.49:1 .
Your dynamic cranking pressure is 145.00 PSI.
V/P (Volume to Pressure Index) is 86
Surely one of you have floored one of those a time or two...
In any case, 86VP sucks!, with a 1700TC and 2.94s. On the street, it took a 2800 and 3.23s just for me to stop laughing at how impossibly weak the bottom end was. And 3.91s only made it a lil more bearable, bringing the power onset to 32mph in first gear.
I did not keep that combo very long.
I returned it to stock and put in in the corner for another day, then sold the X-heads.
Everybody over the age of 60 must have done this at least once in their lifetimes,lol. I did it twice. I guess I was a slow learner.......
that was my experience.
I also, one time, put the entire 318 top-end and cam, into/onto a 340, making it a high compression big-bore 318, which I then dropped into a 65 Valiant wagon. Down South those are called Darts I think.
I installed fenderwell headers and dual 2 inch pipes with Thrush shorty straight thrus ( hey that was ~mid 70s and I mightabeen 25ish)./ Yes I left the 1969 2bbl on it. I used the 273 adjustable gear on the solid barbell lifters, on the 318 cam.
That was a funtastic lil screamer. I don't remember what gears were in the wagon, but the "posi" didn't last long . Nor did the 273-904lol. Actually the 7.25 outlasted the trans by a good bit. After the trans fried, I gave the car to my little brother, together with a spare slanty I had. The deal was I got the 340/904 back. And I did. He drove that poor lil car for a few years afterwards, on the same 7.25,lol..
more anecdotal pennies.
As a streeter;
I'll take the screaming hi-compression lo-po 340, over a lo-compression, big-cam, I don't care what heads, 318, any time.