Actually neither one of you are right or wrong, as, poorly stated
The fact is whether or not you need proportioning depends on weight bias, tires, sizes of brakes whether drum or disc, and so on. A vehicle, light in the rear, with large rear tires and lots of traction, might just need a prop valve with all drum brakes. Or, with front disc/ rear drum, and the same situation, "may not."
And the same may be true (may or may not need) with ANY system, all drum, disk / drum, or all disk.
We are of course also throwing vehicle mods in the mix, meaning mismatched brake components.
IN FACT I AM FIGHTING THAT RIGHT NOW on my 04 GMC. I bypassed the ABS because the brakes sucked and I was having trouble getting them to do much. After converting to hydroboost, and a few other things, I now have a Willwood prop valve to the rear disk, and IT IS NOT ENOUGH. For some reason the rear disks lock up much easier than they should.