Solid vs Hydraulic

-
I think 195 # on the seat is kind of low for a solid roller....especially in a boosted application.
Spring pressure does one thing....in two different ways.
It keeps the roller on the lobe , both at max lift where it keeps the valve from floating and on the seat where it keeps it from bouncing.
I don't know if you're running a ton of boost , M.D. , but I think excessive manifold pressure can blow the valves open without enough spring. Granted , it is only the amount of lash , but there are times when you don't want cylinder filling.
My cam has .4176 lobe lift with 1.6 rockers. I am using Comp 943-16's which have 240# @ 1.9 " and 598# @ 1.25
To the O.P. , you only need to answer one question. Do you mind turning wrenches ?
Yes ? Hydraulic.
No ? Solid.
Solid rollers rev higher , make more power , but require periodic attention.
With good parts , they can stay set for a long time......but should be checked a couple times a season anyway.
Hydraulics........put away wet , add gas , oil , drive , repeat.
If you decide to go solid roller , call Tim at Bullet (662 ) 893-5670 and tell him exactly what you want from your car. he will have questions too , and between the two of you , you will come up with exactly what you need.........and it may well be a hydraulic. He doesn't get paid any more for making you a solid or hydraulic.
But he is very good at what he does.
 
Well all I can say is I leave that stuff up to the professionals. I did call Tim @ Bullet for my camshaft and that is what they recommended for my application. Brian verified it all and set it up accordingly.

What trips me out is the guys on other sites are taking stock parts, small cams, springs etc to unheard of levels, 25PSI Boost Plus and their stuff lives..... I really believe one can truly over think their builds from what I have seen guys get away with on Yellowbullet and theturboforums.com , here 98% of the members are way too conservative and think oh no way that don't make sense and it wont work when in fact they are proven wrong on a daily basis..... Lol

My lash is set at .010 on both the intake and exhaust Per Tim's specs @ Bullet.
 
Seems to me if the post starts with a bad experience, perhaps the original "professional" had your same attitude.
The amount of carnage that some pros are responsible for trips me out.
 
Well all I can say is I leave that stuff up to the professionals. I did call Tim @ Bullet for my camshaft and that is what they recommended for my application. Brian verified it all and set it up accordingly.

What trips me out is the guys on other sites are taking stock parts, small cams, springs etc to unheard of levels, 25PSI Boost Plus and their stuff lives..... I really believe one can truly over think their builds from what I have seen guys get away with on Yellowbullet and theturboforums.com , here 98% of the members are way too conservative and think oh no way that don't make sense and it wont work when in fact they are proven wrong on a daily basis..... Lol

My lash is set at .010 on both the intake and exhaust Per Tim's specs @ Bullet.

I am not being critical as much as I am curious. And I am certainly not the final word on anything that happens outside my garage.
Just struck me as being pretty tame spring pressure.
Ramps have a ton to do with requirements too , though I think force fed motors like an early and quick opening on both sides and a wide lobe angle.
If it works , that is what really matters.
And I do tend to be the over build kid in a lot of instances. A nice fat margin for error never scared me none.:-D
 
Seems to me if the post starts with a bad experience, perhaps the original "professional" had your same attitude.
The amount of carnage that some pros are responsible for trips me out.

Haaa, Lol! All I can say is I give it a 200% Effort and I am not afraid to push the limits at all. If I screw something up I will throw it in the gutter and go build another! :burnout:
 
I am not being critical as much as I am curious. And I am certainly not the final word on anything that happens outside my garage.
Just struck me as being pretty tame spring pressure.
Ramps have a ton to do with requirements too , though I think force fed motors like an early and quick opening on both sides and a wide lobe angle.
If it works , that is what really matters.
And I do tend to be the over build kid in a lot of instances. A nice fat margin for error never scared me none.:-D

No offense taken at all. Just sticking my 2 worthless sense out there.:D
 
[sarcasm]Yep Hyd rollers don't make any power and are no good over 4500rpm...[/sarcasm]

:toothy10:
 
On my latest build I used the comp AMC solid flat tappets that oil the face. I primed it with the manifold off and watched them oil the lobes. I fugure it can't hurt, I just had to get shorter pushrods and so far, so good. Might help a solid flat tappet live a little longer with high spring pressures....
 
On my latest build I used the comp AMC solid flat tappets that oil the face. I primed it with the manifold off and watched them oil the lobes. I fugure it can't hurt, I just had to get shorter pushrods and so far, so good. Might help a solid flat tappet live a little longer with high spring pressures....

I think Johnson Hylift makes those lifters with the EMD hole in them. I used them too and like them a lot.
 
-
Back
Top