briankaplan
greenduster
Sorry I said anything about it. Didn't want to open up a can of worms.
I worked for it. I earned it. I deserve it.
I worked for it. I earned it. I deserve it.
Your original statement was that since taxes are deducted from disability payments then you are somehow a positive force in the tax base. From an economic standpoint, that simply cannot be since you aren't producing any goods or services in lieu of receiving that payment.
YouTube - The Most Persistent Economic Fallacy of All Time!
You don't pay a penny in taxes on SS disability income , only additional income , pension , spouses income , interest etc.
Sorry I said anything about it. Didn't want to open up a can of worms.
I worked for it. I earned it. I deserve it.
From what we were to ld by my wifes attorney SS ises different "guidelines" for different age brackets. Closer you are to retirement age the less stringent the rules are. If you hunt around on the SS website all the info you need to get thru is there, more or less. Some of my paper work was a cut and paste right from there own web site......Appiled in sept 09.Turned down nov 09.Appealed in jan 10.Got aproved on march 10 2010.Will be recieving payment from aug 09 till nov.I worked from may 17 1976- aug 19 2010.I missing working i'm 53 years old .
Glad to hear it didn't take forever to come thru, as is often the case. Back trouble can really affect a person's life.
I must say it gets old when people make judgmental comments; without having the facts, which by the way not so long ago, this subject would be considered personal and nobody's business. What I mean is if the person chose to share it, that's fine, but it's not polite to voice one's disapproval of it.
No, not what I said or meant. A lot of people think disability is a tax free ride. It's just not true. I meant only what I SAID and nothing else. YOU inferred the rest, and incorrectly.
"Somebody wants to take a crack at "their" tax dollars supporting people on disability needs to know that we pay taxes outta that disability too. It's not like people on disability aren't still contributiong to the tax base. We are."
From an Economics standpoint, that is just not possible. Did you watch the Milton Friedman video, I think he does a good job of explaining the principle behind the "broken window" theory.
http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html
Don't take this as a personal attack, it's just a short lesson in economics.
Sorry I said anything about it. Didn't want to open up a can of worms.
I worked for it. I earned it. I deserve it.
I am too glad you got your disability and you do deserve it.Sorry I said anything about it. Didn't want to open up a can of worms.
I worked for it. I earned it. I deserve it.
You bet Brian deserves the disability. And you can guarantee he would rather have his health and job. But being sick enough to qualify for the disability tells the whole story right there.
I can tell you from personal experience Brian. DONT spread it around that your disabled. I have been revictimised several times over just because Im helpless to defend myself.It seems like there are a LOT OF VULTURES waiting to pick on weak folk.
Your better off keeping this within your family and circle of friends.
Just some advise from someone who has been there.
Did you know if you come into the USA and claim you got addicted to drugs after you came here , you are elidgable for max SSD. You also get a $25000.00 start up check to help you make it through rehab. This is for non citizens only. I met a 23 yr. old cuban collecting this. He is also On Medical marajuana. He drives a new Shelby GT500. He does not need a licence or insurance He claimes diplomatic imunity. Now that is a waist of tax dollars. But you don't see that comming out of the budget. It would ultimately effect those who run this country. This is the trueth and it is sad.
First off, a DISCLAIMER! I dont know any of you personally. I am sure everyone here is a good honest person and nothing I am about to say is aimed at any one person or post individually.
Second, to Brian - congrats on winning your case...it was a long haul for you and I am sure that the win lets you breath a sigh of relief for a change.
That said -- since Brian put this out there, its fair game for comment from all, and comment people did! LOL
I think the way this thread flared up the way it did just shows the overall attitude of the average taxpayer of the US.
"I am tired of people living off of my tax money but if I can get some for myself I will take it"
Dont get me wrong. SDI is a godsend to many. Someone who can no longer ambulate around cant do the same kind of work he or she may be accustomed to.
But does that mean that there is NO kind of work that person can do?
And if they CAN do other work, why shouldn;t we as a people insist they do?
I know a person (know them very well) that is on SSDI and continues to work on cars, work on the house etc. Went on SSDI at age 45. He's now 60 ish.
I asked him about how he can still do that kind of work as a hobby when he is claiming he cant do that kind of work at a job.
He says he gets tired easy.
Well, hell...I get tire every day at work and I muddle through somehow.
He had a minor stroke and now pretty much milks it. Meanwhile there are people out there with crippling pain or disabilities who somehow find a way to work and produce.
But hey, its not my call. Its the gubment's. If you can get it, go for it, I tells him.
Problem is, he has to be sneaky about everything he does so he doesnt get turned in to the SSDI folks.....he says they have agents out there who watch for this sort of thing...not sure if that is true or not.
I couldn't live that way.
I, frankly, take offense at the way he does this.
Yeah, he paid into the SSDI system....in the same way that we all pay into our auto insurance or homeowners insurance. Can you imagine if EVERYONE made a claim on their auto insurance all at once? We could bankrupt an industry.
SSDI is nothing more than a nationalized income insurance plan.
To me, he is collecting something that he really shouldnt be due.
He is making it so that the legitimate folks who NEED disability cant get it when the yneed it and that sucks.
I have a bad back...hurts like a **** every day. I also have a bad foot.
Still, I figure that if I can find a way to roam around Carlisle looking at parts and cars or that I can work on my car as a hobby, I should be working.
Maybe my outlook will change as I age.
Only the person collecting SSDI can really say if he/she can or cannot honestly work at a job....any job...or if he/she is just looking to collect.
To those of you currently collecting, God speed and hope you feel better.