Odd shifter problem, need advice

-

Uncle Bob

Shiny paint causes stress.
Joined
Oct 28, 2019
Messages
836
Reaction score
1,213
Location
Almost Heaven, WVa
I've got a problem that is related to my shifter adjustment. The car is a 71 Duster w/360, trans is an A-833, shifter is a Hurst Comp Plus with bolt in handle, linkage and levers are correct. All the rest of the related things for the clutch were sourced new from Brewer's.

At first I noticed that regularly I would grind the gears going into second, so I re-adjusted the shifter, and now it goes cleanly into second but grinds going into first if I don't come to a stop first. There's a lot of slop in the shifter so it seems like maybe I'm chasing the correct adjustment back and forth. So instead of going through the adjustment process again I thought I would ask, is there anyway to say if the current behavior of grinding into first seems related to the rod adjustment being too long or too short?

I understand if the only answer is "rebuild everything you haven't already". But I thought maybe someone had been through this before and might be able to say "lengthen (or shorten) the rod one turn and try again"

Thanks.
 
Inspect the shifter bushings closely. Make sure they are THERE and in good shape. This sounds exactly like worn or missing shift rod bushings.
 
Any possibility that the arms on the trans are not the correct length making the ratio off?

Also if the clutch is not completely releasing that's when I would expect to have grinding.

Lastly if the synchros are too warn they might not be able to do their job
 
Also if you check the above ideas I used to bend the crap of that 1-2 rod and i would have the same issues. The dealer asked what the hell I was using them for.
 
More then likely you have the wrong pedal assembly for your pressure plate. Change the pin spread from 5 1/4 to 6 inch. You will get more release of the pressure plate. This was changed due to the the complaint of pedal being harder to push with the 6 inch spread. This can be done by welding 3/4 inch extension on yours. It will shift easier. Especially into reverse and first

Clutch Pedals A-body.jpg
 
What fluid in the trans?
Penn grade 90wt
Make sure you have the correct neutral position adjustment in the shifter itself.
I put a rod through the shifter before adjusting, are you saying that itself could be wrong?
Inspect the shifter bushings closely. Make sure they are THERE and in good shape. This sounds exactly like worn or missing shift rod bushings.
Bushings where the rods go? There aren't any and there isn't room for them.
More then likely you have the wrong pedal assembly for your pressure plate. Change the pin spread from 5 1/4 to 6 inch. You will get more release of the pressure plate. This was changed due to the the complaint of pedal being harder to push with the 6 inch spread. This can be done by welding 3/4 inch extension on yours. It will shift easier. Especially into reverse and first
The pressure plate is a McLeod diaphragm, pedals are as expected for an A-body.
Any possibility that the arms on the trans are not the correct length making the ratio off?

Also if the clutch is not completely releasing that's when I would expect to have grinding.

Lastly if the synchros are too warn they might not be able to do their job
The synchros looked OK before I installed the transmission. I was leaning towards those being the problem until I re-adjusted and the grind moved from 2nd gear to first.

The arms look right and are turned the correct way. Ditto the rods. This is the best photo I've got of them.
1730119162183.png

I won't be surprised if it's on me and I'm not putting the pedal on the floor. Will pay attention next time.


I wondered about those adjusters because they look as if they limit the shifter throw. Will definitely watch that video today.
 
Penn grade 90wt

I put a rod through the shifter before adjusting, are you saying that itself could be wrong?

Bushings where the rods go? There aren't any and there isn't room for them.

The pressure plate is a McLeod diaphragm, pedals are as expected for an A-body.

The synchros looked OK before I installed the transmission. I was leaning towards those being the problem until I re-adjusted and the grind moved from 2nd gear to first.

The arms look right and are turned the correct way. Ditto the rods. This is the best photo I've got of them.
View attachment 1716320674
I won't be surprised if it's on me and I'm not putting the pedal on the floor. Will pay attention next time.


I wondered about those adjusters because they look as if they limit the shifter throw. Will definitely watch that video today.

If the levers are centered the shifter should work. Sometimes you need to go a turn either way the get the shifter on center. The fluid is good. The rest is in the transmission.
 
If the levers are centered the shifter should work. Sometimes you need to go a turn either way the get the shifter on center. The fluid is good. The rest is in the transmission.
The levers are centered as good as they can be both at the transmission and the shifter using a rod through the centering holes.

I noticed a lot of slop in at least the reverse side of things. There were about 5 turns of range on the reverse rod and it would still fit on both ends. I put it in the middle of that.
 
Read this and you'll be able to fix your issues. I did this to many A-bodies having your same problem and they shifted like butter even at a complete stop. Also if you installed a Diaphragm clutch you must remove the over center spring on the pedal assembly. Been playing and street racing these cars since the 70's. There are 2 different clutch pedal assemblies used. With a borg and beck three finger pressure plate you must use the heavier spring red which calls for the side brace used on earlier assemblies. If not start doing squats to strengthen your legs.

https://www.motortrend.com/how-to/mopp-1012-four-speed-a-body-clutch-pedal-adjustment/

The red spring style is 6 inch the blue spring style is 5 1/4.

100_0043 (2).JPG
 
Read this and you'll be able to fix your issues. I did this to many A-bodies having your same problem and they shifted like butter even at a complete stop. Also if you installed a Diaphragm clutch you must remove the over center spring on the pedal assembly. Been playing and street racing these cars since the 70's. There are 2 different clutch pedal assemblies used. With a borg and beck three finger pressure plate you must use the heavier spring red which calls for the side brace used on earlier assemblies. If not start doing squats to strengthen your legs.

https://www.motortrend.com/how-to/mopp-1012-four-speed-a-body-clutch-pedal-adjustment/

The red spring style is 6 inch the blue spring style is 5 1/4.

View attachment 1716320714
The OC spring is out. This unit had the side brace and needle bearings. I will see if I can get a reasonably accurate measurement under the dash, but apparently the side brace (red spring) signals the longer throw?
 
The OC spring is out. This unit had the side brace and needle bearings. I will see if I can get a reasonably accurate measurement under the dash, but apparently the side brace (red spring) signals the longer throw?
I painted the springs red and blue for reference. They were not painted on these sets . But the side brace would usually identify the 6 inch style.

I have seen the pedal being depressed all the way causing the pressure plate fingers to hit the clutch plate springs and then fingers to drive the clutch disc. If you have a diaphragm clutch you must remove the large over center spring. This spring will hold the pedal down at RPM's due to the diaphragm pressure plate not having the centrifugal weights for release.

If I were you I would call Dan at Brewers. You may have a synchronizer issue. He sells an upgraded set and they work great. I installed a set in a Barracuda they stop the gear instantly for a smooth engagement.
 
The spring that came out measures about 7" from end to end, from the inside of the curl to the other inside curl. It has some orange paint on it. I'm pretty sure I've got the good assembly in it.

I adjusted the pedal for whatever the FSM called for on clearance at the fork. There's not much free play at all. Your description sounds like it can be adjusted too tight, to where the PP can push the disc back toward the flywheel. I will revisit that and maybe dial a little more free play into it.

I'm trying to avoid pulling the trans back out and apart because I've got a car coming back from paint soon so I need to be able to move this car out of the way to get the freshly painted one inside. A rebuild wouldn't hurt the trans, but as I mentioned the synchros looked OK to me and the trans isn't noisy at all. It's just the aggravation of grinding gears.

Q2AzwQ2.jpeg

s9a8V8F.jpeg

s9a8V8F.jpeg
 
We're it mine, I'd make sure carpet or something wasn't restricting pedal travel.
Then I'd adjust the he clutch so throw out bearing is touching clutch fingers ( to be properly adjusted later ), to get as much disc/pp departure distance at max.
The grind is mismatched shaft speed which syncros are supposed to match by slowing one down.
If clutch disc is dragging, syncr can't stop it, = grind.
This is where AJ would go into syncro cone depth etc, it's a good read, but another thread.
So either syncros worn, ( this is where I usually trade #4 syncro/little use, for #2 syncro/hard use).
Or lube isn't being "dispersed" fast enuff from syncro surface, thus syncro is non-effective.
He would likely suggest 50/50 gear oil/ATF.

Summary . Adjust throw out brg temporarily to eliminate clutch throw distance.
Change lube, see AJ post .
Me, I'd prepare to change syncros. jmo.

Good luck
 
If I was a betting man, I'd bet that you have two or even three problems.
1) an elusive gate
2) inadequate clutch departure
3) possible in need of new brass or at least deglazing the cones.

1) as to the Elusive gate
I'll bet those external levers are moving around on the studs. This is a common problem as the parts age.
The best solution I have found is
1) to remove the nuts, and the levers, then put some silicone grease down into cavity around the stud to isolate the shaft from the cover, in preparation to the next step which is
2) reinstall the levers and red loc-tite the cavities around the studs and the lever corners. Fill it right up. , then
3) reinstall the nuts with any locking agent
4) let dry.

I do this with the cover on the bench, so I can really fill the cavities. IDK how effective it will be with the cover installed and in the car. The point is that the hardened Red loc-tite turns to stone in there and even after many years, my levers still are immovable on the studs. That is the goal. It matters not how you achieve that.
5) now center your shifter and immobilize it in the gate.
6) fit the rods. Both ends should be a tight fit to the holes in the levers. If you have more than about 1 turn play on the adjuster, that's not good. By two turns, you gotta fix it or slow down your shifting technique. Reverse don't count. It can be sloppy as heck.
That takes care of finding and moving thru the gate.

2) as to clutch departure;
If everything was new and perfectly aligned, you could get away with as little as .060 on the diaphragm clutch. If the disc is wobbling on the input gear or, or the input is sloppy loose in the pilot-bushing, then you need more. I run my organic at 080 on initial set-up but after that I never keep track, just adjusting it as necessary .
I tried a CF-II disc but found it too aggressive, that's an opinion. It broke almost everything behind it; that's a fact.
BTW,
with the right pedal ratio, You do not need to push the clutch pedal all the way to the floor to achieve adequate departure. You just go until it doesn't drag or grind gears Without a pedal-stop. on the floor, finding that ever elusive departure is a bit of a guessing game.
Here's what I mean;
>finding reverse might require a lot of departure, cuz the disc has a tendency not to stop spinning. The pilot bushing is grabbing it on the end, and the TO is spinning on the fingers. Any drag from the PP/flywheel is also nipping at it. So for reverse, I push down on the pedal a long way, and cuz reverse is not synchronized, I pick the right moment and slam it in there.
> Engaging First from a stop can have a different problem. If the brass is grabby, it can stop the gear with all the clutching teeth misaligned, and no amount of slamming the shifter will get it in. This is a common thing. So the trick is to not be stopped when going for First gear. Obviously that is not possible. But the output stopped and the cluster still creeping is the same thing, so in this case, I WANT the cluster tio be creeping ot the car to be creeping. In either case, this is now a matter of clutch departure and timing. If you are running 140 EP oil, the cluster will practically stop spinning instantly, and the possibility of butting the teeth is very great. Conversely running ATF, the gears will keep on spinning for a long time, and there you sit at a green-light waiting, which sux, So you gotta know your trans, to go for the N>1 shift and stick it. I;ve been run 50/50 dextron-II and 85/90 EP for many decades, so we're old pals.
All other shifts in the A833 are splits of about 72% So whatever rpm you leave a gear, the Rs will drop TO that % going into the next gear, so then, you can pick an rpm or roadspeed and learn to always shift there, and you can use the same shift timing/departure whatever works.
For instance, I like to upshift at 2800rpm. which means the rpm has to drop to 2000, for a jam-it-in and go deal, no input from the brass required at all. If I shift at 5000, I am looking for 3600 to jam it in. and so on. The point being if you are half decent close on the rpm, your clutch departure can be anything, and it will go in just fine, no brass required.
So for this style of shifting, you can be pretty inattentive.

3) As to the brass
However, I get it, sometimes you are gonna be off in lala land and you pull the stick and get grinding. This has NOTHING To do with your neutral gate. Yur already knocking on the brass saying gimmee. If it grinds and the departure is adequate, then the problem is inside the trans, and the only fix is marrying the brass to the cones.
The brass needs four things;
1) a brass that bites; not bent or oval
2) a cone to bite on; not glazed or ridged at the base
3) a high on the brake engagement; making it last longer
4) and strut springs that keep the push on the struts, jamming them into the slider, to keep pushing the brass for as long as possible; cuz if the slider starts moving too soon, well; grind me a pound.

Other
Rarely is/are the brass to blame,, unless they are worn out and sitting too low.
Usually the cones are glazed or the strut-springs are lazy.
Btw, don't run straight 140wt unless maybe your in a desert, cuz two reasons, 1) the cluster stops spinning like instantly, and 2) that oil is really hard to squeeze out from between the brass and the brake-cone; and until the brass is actually on the metal, braking cannot occur. Don't even run a dual-grade 140, lol.
IMO, run the 50/50 and you'll be happy.
IMO, do not run a synthetic trans oil; this is an opinion. The fact is; I couldn't make it do what I needed to do, which was, to shift like lightning, lol.
When all else fails, the A230 sliders will work in a late A833, but the struts are different. And, the Late synchronizer assemblies can be swapped into an older box, but again, with the matching struts (and hubs).
I have had these come in with mis-matched struts to sliders, and the result is grinding, as the sliders are flopping around on the struts, this type of grinding cannot be cured except by parts replacement.

Ok that's all I got; I hope you find something useful.

BTW
the clutch fork at rest, should be almost all the way to the engine side of the BH window leaving just enough room for the boot. If it is not, then you can get departure problems.
As I recall there are two fork-brackets, and you guessed it one is high and the other is low, for two different applications. There are also multiple forks for different applications. @brewersperformance has a pretty good description of when to use what.

BTW-2
IMO, by looking at an installed synchronizer assy, you can't really tell anything about how it WILL WORK, in the future;
except you can maybe tell how it HAS WORKED in the past, by the sharpness of the clutching teeth.
You can assume, if the teeth are sharp, that it is working fine,
but that could just be because the operator was gentle on it. You don't know
if he just HAD TO BE GENTLE, because the thing was lazy.
You cannot even assume a brand new one directly from Chrysler WILL WORK.
You have to take it apart and test it,
unless you don't mind doing things multiple times........ which I'm getting pretty good at.
 
Last edited:
More then likely you have the wrong pedal assembly for your pressure plate. Change the pin spread from 5 1/4 to 6 inch. You will get more release of the pressure plate. This was changed due to the the complaint of pedal being harder to push with the 6 inch spread. This can be done by welding 3/4 inch extension on yours. It will shift easier. Especially into reverse and first

View attachment 1716320541
Not to throw a wrench into this scenario, but I have run across 3 different pin spreads on the A-body pedals. My Demon has the 5.25" spread, and I have no problem power shifting at 6,000 RPM with a mild SB. Even has the larger 10.9" clutch disc.

A HD 6.00 PIN SPREAD.jpg


A STD 5.25 PIN SPREAD.jpg


A STD 5.62 PIN SPREAD.jpg
 
Dan, Power shifting was never the problem for me with either. I found the 6 " always shifted into reverse and other gears easier when the car wasn't moving. But I never tried this with your upgraded synchronizers

What I did see was when the diaphragm style pressure plate is used with the over center spring in place and you pull a gear while holding the throttle flat to the floor. " Flat Shifting" The pressure plate will not re-engage until you let off the throttle and the RPM's come down. Just ran into this with the Barracuda for Todd I built that trans for that needed the second gear that was popping out of gear.

I myself only ever had 5 1/4 and 6" pin spread . I never saw any other spreads but that doesn't mean they were never produced.
 
I've got a problem that is related to my shifter adjustment. The car is a 71 Duster w/360, trans is an A-833, shifter is a Hurst Comp Plus with bolt in handle, linkage and levers are correct. All the rest of the related things for the clutch were sourced new from Brewer's.

At first I noticed that regularly I would grind the gears going into second, so I re-adjusted the shifter, and now it goes cleanly into second but grinds going into first if I don't come to a stop first. There's a lot of slop in the shifter so it seems like maybe I'm chasing the correct adjustment back and forth. So instead of going through the adjustment process again I thought I would ask, is there anyway to say if the current behavior of grinding into first seems related to the rod adjustment being too long or too short?

I understand if the only answer is "rebuild everything you haven't already". But I thought maybe someone had been through this before and might be able to say "lengthen (or shorten) the rod one turn and try again"

Thanks.
I always use Synthetic Disc Brake Grease on my linkages as it persists and is very resistant to wash-out.

What are you running for trans lube? That can cause the synchronizers to drag.

Are you lining up the shifter with a drill bit on the underside opposite the shift handle?

I struggled for decades getting the shifting and clutch adjusted correctly. Then I finally spent the time to optimize the clutch linkage so all the rods and Z-bar connecting points are square to each other and sit flat on the pads where it connected. Use the same grease on it. It made all the difference as it allowed it to work without deflection from bent and misaligned parts.

Then, I installed a hydraulic clutch, and it improved shifting to the next level.
 
-
Back
Top